Why Locals Love Original Brooklyn Pie Co.
Nestled in the heart of Round Rock, TX, Original Brooklyn Pie Co. serves up an authentic taste of New York-style pizza that transports you straight to the bustling streets of Brooklyn. This cozy pizza spot specializes in thin-crust pies that strike the perfect balance between crispy and chewy, creating a mouthwatering canvas for their rich, flavorful toppings.
The menu is a celebration of bold, crafted flavors. The Mona Lisa Chicken is a standout, combining tender chicken with savory mushrooms, smoky bacon, fresh spinach, and creamy gorgonzola, resulting in a sophisticated medley that lingers deliciously on the palate. If you’re drawn to familiar comfort, the Meat Lovers pie delivers a generous helping of pepperoni, ham, bacon, and sausage, each bite bursting with hearty, meaty goodness. For those craving a classic touch, the Margherita enchants with its delicate brush of olive oil and garlic sauce, topped with fresh mozzarella, ripe Roma tomatoes, and fragrant basil – simple ingredients elevated to perfection. Not to be missed, the White Castle Cheeseburger pizza offers a playful twist, combining hamburger, red onions, crispy bacon, and sharp cheddar for a flavor-packed experience.
Beyond pizzas, their calzones are equally exceptional. The Meat Calzone, stuffed with sausage, pepperoni, and a luscious blend of ricotta and mozzarella, arrives piping hot with a side of zesty marinara sauce, inviting you to savor every warm, cheesy bite. The Veggie Calzone offers a garden-fresh alternative, loaded with bell peppers, mushrooms, tomatoes, onions, ricotta, and mozzarella—perfectly balanced and satisfying.
The atmosphere at Original Brooklyn Pie Co. reflects its NY roots with an authentic Italian pizzeria vibe, small yet vibrant. Inside, the space is intimate and warmly decorated, reminiscent of a quirky Brooklyn slice shop, giving the experience a genuine local feel. While seating is limited, the friendly buzz and outdoor dining area provide a relaxed setting to enjoy your meal. Be sure to come prepared for a no-frills drink selection that pairs well with their hearty pies—from classic Mexican Coke crafted with pure cane sugar to refreshing Powerade and flavorful sodas in convenient bottles.
Customer reviews paint a lively picture: Mike Crane raves about their in-house made meat calzones, describing them as generously loaded with savory meats and cheese, perfectly complemented by marinara. Julie Catalan calls the giant slice “amazing,” praising its satisfying crispiness and ideal thin crust that’s become their go-to. Though some feedback notes the limited seating and occasionally brisk service, the overwhelming sentiment appreciates the authentic flavors and culinary pride that makes this pizzeria a standout in the area.
For those who crave a true, no-compromise New York pizza experience without leaving Central Texas, Original Brooklyn Pie Co. offers a flavorful escape that delights the senses and honors the traditions of Brooklyn’s beloved pie culture. Whether grabbing a quick slice or indulging in a loaded specialty calzone, the passion for quality and bold taste shines through every bite.
See the Space & Food
What Makes This Place Friendly
- Identifies as Black-owned
- Outdoor seating
- Delivery
- Takeaway
- Dine-in
- Lunch
- Dinner
- Solo dining
- Wheelchair-accessible car park
- Wheelchair-accessible entrance
- Comfort food
- Quick bite
- Vegetarian options
- Lunch
- Dinner
- Catering
- Dessert
- Seating
- Table service
- Casual
- University students
- Accepts reservations
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
- NFC mobile payments
- Credit cards
- Good for kids
- High chairs
- Free of charge street parking
- Free parking lot
- Parking
- Dogs allowed outside
Real Reviews from the Community
- Mar 12, 2026
Very good meat calzone which was made in-house! Loaded with pepperoni and sausage and cheese. Also came with some marinara sauce. Lunch special came with a drink. Highly recommended!
- Mar 9, 2026
Wanting a slice for lunch we popped on into OBPC to fill that need. As you walk in you are meet with a little space with a big atmosphere. Surrounded by decor fit for Italian pizza shop. You're greeted with a small table and an L bracket of standing space and chairs. There are no restrooms and the drinks are In cans in bottles. Now you're met with a couple options here at lunch. Their staple is a slice. A drink the two toppings for $9. I opted to get the slice, the salad and the drink for 13 as that salad choices are Greek house or Caesar. Be quite a few choices of toppings. I decided to go pepperoni and black olives. My wife went with ham and pineapple. She got the Greek salad. I got the Caesar salad. Which the salads did come out first. My Caesar came out cold and the greek had lots of toppings. Halfway through our salads we received our slices of pie and oh let me tell you it's as big as it looks. You are definitely getting two slices of pie stick together to make the one big huge slice which they offer. I definitely think this was my slice size to perfection. My wife couldn't finish her crust. That being said she wouldn't have changed it any other way. She'd try every time. If you're looking for a slice at lunch time, this is a really great deal. They offer larger pizzas in the 14in and 18-in sizes. A 18-in cheese I believe is $21. Specialty pizzas range from $30 to $40 and you can feed six eight people with the 18-in.
- Mar 5, 2026
Brooklyn Pie offers a solid NY style pizza. This particular location isn't ideal however. On this particular visit they were not prepared at open and the did not acknowledge us as they counted changed, prepared the soda machine and put down stools. Consistently indifferent service. The other bad thing about this location is their insistence on playing music extremely loud. Loud house music. Very little seating inside. Today the slice of pizza was the greasiest I have ever had here. It took a few paper towels to bring it to a reasonable level of grease. Overall it's a good slice of pizza but not an enjoyable place to eat for lunch. Edit: After several more visits I am adding a star to my review of Brooklyn Pie in Round Rock. It has been really good and consistent and they do a great Greek salad.
- Feb 28, 2026
Food was amazing but I'm not sure why the staff seemed so grumpy last time. We've been going here for years, some of the best pizza you'll find around if you like that northeastern corridor Pizza. Pricey but worth it. Not much seating, strongly recommend taking it to go.
- Jan 25, 2026
Wanted to try a new pizza place. We love pizza. Their calzones were DELICIOUS. And the giant slice??? AMAZING. My husband said we found our new go to for thin crust. The giant slice is crispy and GIANT. We don't like much on our pizza, just pep, but they had some good variety of toppings. It is pretty small inside, but they have outdoor seating thats not very noisy and with the weather getting cooler, was perfect. We had it to go, we had a small child that was ready for a nap, but next time we'll definitely take advantage of the seating outside. Like I said, new spot for us!
- Jan 24, 2026
There is not enough New York style pizza in Round rock. I am so happy Brooklyn pie co is here. Cindy working the register is always kind and helpful. The slices are bigger than your face!
- Dec 2, 2025
First, my credentials (pretentious ): I grew up in NYC and spent the better part of my life living there with pizza being my favorite food and have studied the ingredients and history of pizza. Original Brooklyn Pie Co.'s crust, sauce, and cheese all taste as accurate as I'd expect outside of NYC. I'm not sure if they use San Marzano tomatoes in their sauce, for example, but the level of sweetness is spot on. The crispiness is just about perfect, too. A lot of places claim to make "NY Style" pizza and fail miserably. This place got it right. Beyond making good pizza, the place has the feeling of a corner pizza shop, which is really hard to find outside of NYC. Finally, the slices are almost ridiculously large lol (see picture for reference). This place is my new favorite pizza place in this area and I'm excited to come back. I recommend it!
- Nov 25, 2025
First off, the slice was HUGE. Definitely a great deal for the price. The sauce had a really nice robust herb flavor that stood out and tasted fresh. Customer service was good and everything came out quick, which I appreciated. Almost 5 stars for me. I just wish the slice was a little crispier, but that’s honestly just my personal preference. Overall solid spot and I’ll definitely be back.
